Ask Leo! by Leo A. Notenboom

What backup program should I use?

Search First! Then browse: Categories | Full Archive | By Date | Newsletter

Home » General Computing » Maintenance and Backup

Comments

Read the article that everyone's commenting on.
RSS feed Subscribe to the RSS Feed for comments on this article.

Comment Page:  1  |  2  |  3  |  4  |  5  |  6  |  7 

Hi Leo.
I am looking for a backup software that can make a different daily backup of some selected data for a week and start after to overwrite the first once again. So that I could go a little back in the backup in case I lost some data. Could you advice me a product? Thanks a lot! Christian ;)

Posted by: Christian Meid at June 5, 2008 3:29 PM

In reading this series of comments, I went to check my own software, PCCloneEx, since I had never really tried to restore anything with it. The program seems to work, but when it restores files it leaves them in a zipped format. I know I can simply unzip it, but are there back-up programs that will restore the file in its native format?

Thanks,

HG

Most backup programs actually restore to original format. Restoring only .zip is ... unusual.

-Leo

Posted by: Harrison Gardner at July 31, 2008 12:15 PM

I have backed up my Windows XP and Office on a 16GB Flash Drive. If my hard drive fails, can I just boot from the Flash Drive, then copy all the backed-up files to the replacement drive? Or, will I need some interim step?

It really depends on how you're backing up. Some backup programs will do as you describe, but most do not. You'll likely need some kind of interim boot disk at a minimum.

-Leo

Posted by: Richard Goodman at August 23, 2008 5:43 PM

Acronis only restores to the backed up computer. I want backup software that will backup to a new computer. If mine crashes I will purchase a new computer. What program should I use? Thanks. Jay

I'm not aware of a *backup* program that will do what you're asking for. Moving software from one computer to another is typically way more complex than just putting the files from one computer onto another.

My recommendation for setting up a new computer is that you set it up ... install everything for that computer on that computer. Then transfer data - perhaps using your backups. Most backup programs work fine for that.
- Leo
05-Oct-2008

Posted by: Jay at October 4, 2008 9:19 AM

Restoring to a new computer seems to be like doing illegal copies of your OS.
But what if your hard disk crashes? I had to deal with that problem: I had a 80GB hd and it crashes. Hd I could buy was 200GB. Backup programs simply made a first partition but I loose 120GB. I had to reinstall all to be able to use the whole disk.
Is there a backup program able to do this tasks?

Posted by: Victor at November 9, 2008 6:31 AM

I recently bought Acronis, because of recommendations here, to use on my wife's laptop, Vista OS, and the program comes back with a failure window every way we have tried to make a drive image whether onto a USB external drive, networked computer, or network drive. Acronis will make backups of e-mails and docs but it is very slow. Their support is not only slow but has been unable to provide a workable answer for image making failure and a password problem getting onto the network drive. They suggested using router password for the later.
I think I am going to trash Acronis and buy new Ghost program which (Version 9)has worked for years on my desktop computer. I do regular backups of data but want regular full drive images in case of drive failures, of wich I've had only three in twenty five years of computers. I probably should consider myself very lucky.

Posted by: Bob at December 9, 2008 1:48 PM

If I back up everything then am I not risking backing up, and then restoring, the bad stuff? Not just something catastrophic like a virus but all the registry crud that might be slowing me down?


(If I'm worried about a hard drive crash, or a fire, I would want to restore to everything exactly as it was.)


I suppose I should buy the program and try out the settings. Besides my data (and I can copy that easily enough) I'll want various applications, and also various settings (I've got my start menu and my desktop just the way I like them.) How do I back up and restore the good while leaving the bad?

A backup program is not a cleaning tool. It's purpose is to save and restore files, or your entire system, to a previous state. So this concept of "restoring the good but not the bad" isn't really looking at what the tool is supposed to be about.

So if you need to restore an entire system, then that's what you should expect, the entire system as of the time you took the backup. That's the point.

Most all backups also allow you to restore individual files, so in cases where you don't need to restore everything, you can pick and chose individual files to recover from your backup.

But if you're trying to clean your system, other methods are much more appropriate.
- Leo
31-Dec-2008

Posted by: David Chesler at December 30, 2008 9:17 AM

I don't think Leo mentioned that often many external hard drives come with a backup function as well. Such as my mybook I got (by western digital) came with.

Posted by: Matthew at January 7, 2009 7:01 AM

Leo, I am not real bright when it comes to computers.But, I do know that my computer XP has a virus that anit virus programs will not touch. And I also know that I have lots of stuff on my computer that is very important to my business. I also know that '10 Quick Steps' is not working.
Do you recommend any off site storage businesses?? I need to save MS Office and its files. HELP, and thanks for your time.

Posted by: George at February 2, 2009 10:23 AM

Because of a failing hard drive, I backed up my system using both Macrium Reflect and the backup tool in Windows XP Home onto a separate external hard drive.
My plan is to replace my laptop hard drive and use the (external) backup to restore the system back to it's current state.

My question is, once I install the new blank hard drive, how do I get the system going again? That is, do I simply hook up the external HD with the backup on it, and hope the computer finds the backup files automatically?

Or do I need to install windows or something on the new internal HD first?

The problem here is that windows was preinstalled on my dell laptop, so i have no windows CD to work with.

Many thanks!

No, it won't just magically work. You'll need to check the documentation that came with your backup tools on how to restore to a bare system.
- Leo
10-Feb-2009
Posted by: mike at February 9, 2009 8:57 AM
Comment Page:  1  |  2  |  3  |  4  |  5  |  6  |  7 
Read the article that everyone's commenting on.
RSS feed Subscribe to the RSS Feed for comments on this article.
Post a Comment

To post a comment on "What backup program should I use?", please return to that article's main page.

Question? Ask Leo!