Helping people with computers... one answer at a time.

Deception online is trivially easy with today's technologies. There's more snake-oil on the internet than ever before - how do you know what's legit?

A very good friend - a mentor and inspiration for Ask Leo!, in fact - has fallen victim to a particularly nasty form of fraud. It turns into an important lesson for all of us in understanding what we can, and cannot believe on the internet.

Here's the scenario...

There's a web site that, for lack of a better term, promotes a "get rich quick" scheme. I'm not going to name names, because I don't want to give them any press or links or page views. In fact, the specifics aren't important here - the situation, however, is.

On this web site, near the bottom is a glowing testimonial. From my friend.

A testimonial that he never provided.

The testimonial is much like you'd see on any web site trying to sell you something. It shows his smiling picture, a photograph of a check made out to him in some large amount, and includes a description of his story, and glowing words about what this particular product did for him.

"In short: don't believe everything you read on the internet."

The problem is that it's all fake.

He never used the product. He never gave an endorsement.

The photo of my friend was stolen from his web site, and the photo of the check is a photoshopped fake.

The pretty words that are his "endorsement"? Total fabrication. Lies.

The entire scenario is fraud, at its most blatant.

And aside from reporting it to the appropriate authorities (which he has done), and getting angry about it (definitely), or perhaps engaging an attorney (I'm sure he's considering it), there's actually little to be done that will force any immediate reaction or retraction.

What does this all mean to you?

A mutual friend, Paul Myers, wrote in his newsletter about this very same scenario:

Here's something you won't hear a lot of copywriters say:

Do not believe anything you read in a testimonial unless you know the person giving it, or the person selling the product, well enough that the testimonial doesn't matter anyway.

If you only know the person giving the testimonial, you may want to ask if they really did say what the sales page claims they said.

In short: don't believe everything you read on the internet.

People often joke about that statement, and I'll admit it's kind of odd for me to remind you of it given that I make my living these days by publishing on the internet. But really, how often do you blindly assume that what you find after a Google search is in fact legitimate? Or that a web site you stumble upon happens to be on the up-and-up?

Or that the testimonial or customer feedback you find is actually legitimate?

How often do you take the time to research - really research - a business or a business opportunity that you find on the internet?

That's the key: don't assume. Double check.

As Paul points out above, you can't just assume testimonials on websites are valid - they could be completely made up, and sadly they often are. And even if not that blatantly fabricated, to once again quote Paul:

You might also be surprised to know how many of the testimonials you see aren't from paying customers at all. A lot of them are nice things people say about the product in return for getting a free copy.

That's even something I have to be careful of here on Ask Leo!. I do get offered free copies of things (which I generally, politely, decline) in exchange for a positive review. That's not how I operate.

But it's not uncommon.

My advice?

Be cautious. Take recommendations only from places (or people) you already trust, and even then with a grain of salt. If you're about to purchase something based on testimonials (or customer reviews, or blog comments or other similar content) consider the source, and in particular, consider how trivial it would be for that to be totally bogus. Talk to people - real people - who you know and trust who've used whatever it is you're considering.

I'm not saying that all reviews or testimonials are bogus - I'm just saying that when it comes to parting with your money, there are many people who will go through great lengths to convince you of just about anything. Making stuff up is just one approach that they're not above using.

Stealing the image of, and attributing fake praise to an otherwise trusted, legitimate resource is just one example. Making stuff up.

Fraud.

To be clear - I'm not saying "don't shop on line", or "don't respond to offers on the internet". There's a ton of really good stuff out there, from legitimate businesses and individuals. To pass it all up due to fear would be just as foolish as believing everything you read.

You do simply need to take a little responsibility for taking an extra step or two to verify that you're doing business with a legitimate entity.

And you need to know what you can - and cannot - trust.

The internet no different than life in general that way.

(As an aside, if you're a writer, a copy-writer, a budding internet marketer or entrepreneur - I do recommend Paul Myer's TalkBiz News newsletter. Paul's an effective and highly entertaining writer himself and he shares many of his tips, advice - and occasional rants - that are all incredibly educational. And yes, this is a testimonial, no he didn't ask for it, and yes if you were to verify it with me some other way you'd get the same message. He's legit. Smile)

Article C4150 - February 16, 2010 « »

Share this article with your friends:

Share this article on Facebook Tweet this article Email a link to this article
Leo Leo A. Notenboom has been playing with computers since he was required to take a programming class in 1976. An 18 year career as a programmer at Microsoft soon followed. After "retiring" in 2001, Leo started Ask Leo! in 2003 as a place for answers to common computer and technical questions. More about Leo.

Not what you needed?

12 Comments
Mark Jacobs (Team Leo)
February 17, 2010 8:01 AM

Here's my unsolicited testimony. Try the WOT (web of trust) plug in for Firefox and IE. It's a user rated service that warns about untrustworthy websites. It's not perfect but it's a good tool in avoiding scams. BTW they give Ask Leo an excellent rating. :)

Michael Horowitz
February 22, 2010 10:17 AM

The Internet needs a User Guide, learning by making mistakes can be quite costly.

Sadly, the point here also applies to messages, warnings, pop-ups and the like from your computer. You can't trust them either. So many people get tricked by phony virus infection warnings. Below is a link to an example I recently wrote about, regarding a warning to upgrade the Flash Player plugin. In this case the warning was mostly legit, but the point being, most people can't judge these things. Sad state of affairs.

http://blogs.computerworld.com/15629/adobe_goofs_on_flash_player_version_warning

howiem
February 23, 2010 8:50 AM

Leo, Good article, but I think that the site should be named. Ond of the great things about the internet is that the word (both good and bad) gets around. I somehow doubt tht identifying a site as containing a false endorsement is grounds for a lawsuit, and you seem to have plenty of proof that it is doing just that. On the other hand if you know that authorities are investigating the site and do not want to directly alert the site owner(s), not ID'ing it makes sense.

I agree with you on WOT. I have seen legitimate sites blocked by WOT because some people did not like the political views expressed on the site. OT and other tools should not involve itself in blocking free speech, but it does. I'd recommend that Firefox users use Link Extend as well, since it shows the site ratings by a number of product vendors similar to WOT, like SiteAdvisor, WOT, Browser Defender, and about 3-4 others. https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/10777

My friend has idenfied the site publicly, and has contacted the appropriate authorities with all the details, so there's no real benefit to be had by my naming names here. (Though perhaps I should head out to WOT and post a review on it. Smile)
Leo
24-Feb-2010

jwildhair
February 23, 2010 10:28 AM

A friend and entertainment promoter used to dissect reviews from legitimate wire sources. If the press called a production an incredible flop, he would say that critics called the show "incredible..." and simply omit the word flop. Though this wasn't a fabrication, it wasn't the WHOLE truth; some of his means were less than licit. When confronted and questioned about his tactics, he said, [i]"Kid,"[/i] (I was only 30 something at the time) [i]"never let the truth stand in the way of a good promotion."[/i] I say, take that advice and apply it wherever you think it fits.

Mike
February 23, 2010 11:05 AM

It's not just the internet, and it's not just hick rubes getting taken for a ride. May I point out a recent name? Bernie Madoff? The internet is no better, or worse, an investment venue than the other channels.

Rohn
February 23, 2010 12:07 PM

As tricky dick said "Trust but verify"

Even internet "experts" must be suspect. Have you read about the expert, Randall C Kennedy, who quoted his alias, Devil Mountain CTO Craig Barth, for stories. More info at:

http://blogs.zdnet.com/BTL/?p=31024&tag=nl.e019

Actually that was Ronald Reagan, but the sentiment is accurate. As I've said before, everything on the internet is best approached with a very healthy dose of skepticism.
Leo
24-Feb-2010
Tom R.
February 23, 2010 1:34 PM

Tricky Dick didn't say "Trust, but verify," Ronald Reagan said it.

http://www.reagan.utexas.edu/archives/speeches/1987/120887c.htm

Ravi Agrawal
February 23, 2010 10:12 PM

I just google with the words product and review where product is the particular item we are wanting to learn about.

There is no need to even visit those webpages. The opening lines say everything about it. Good or bad.

Ravi.

Glenn P.
February 27, 2010 2:02 AM

First, a Pet Peeve: "Internet", not "internet", always. It's a proper noun. You might notice, Leo, that you've got your commenters doing it, too -- grrrr! Please! ALWAYS capitalize the word "Internet", folks! That's the correct spelling & usage!

Now: with THAT off my chest...

The way I typically decide on the trustworthiness of a recommendation (especially a computer program) is based upon the trustworthiness of the recommender. I happen to have a short list of what I might term "Trusted Recommenders" -- perhaps they might be of interest to you. In no particular order:

  1. Bob Rankin and/or Patrick Crispin (The Internet Tourbus)
  2. Brian Livingston and/or Fred Langa et. al (WindowsSecrets)
  3. Kim Komando (Her multitudinous varieties of E-Newsletter)
  4. And of course (need I even say it?) Leo A. Notenboom (Ask Leo!)

I have come to respect these sources as reliable and trustworthy, and any recommendation any of them might offer is generally presumed valid and safe, at least initially and barring any counterindication, and particularly so if more than one of them has mentioned the same item.

More generally, good spelling, proper grammar, and a clean page counts for something (not much, but something). If I see an item on a page free of errors, I tend to believe the item itself is likelier than otherwise to itself be error-free. On the other hand, if the page is full of typos or spelling mistakes or grammatical errors, it doesn't much matter the reputation of the page-writer, I don't put a lot of faith in what he writes just on that basis alone! Who would trust in the carefulness of a person -- a programmer, perhaps? -- who is too careless, even to SPELL correctly?!?

sirpaul1
March 9, 2010 11:47 PM

None of those 'trust programs' are up to date although some are better than others.
If a web site makes a change to something nefarious (or vice versa), they won't be 'updated' till the next sweep. I use WOT. I've had to say "Oops!" a few times and I've been to 'red' sites and not had any problems.
And it's 'e-mail' not 'email'. Kinda like 'snail mail' not 'snailmail'!

Oxios
June 13, 2010 12:36 AM

So if what you say is true then I can't trust you. lol Im kiddin nice article though I think you got it.

doubter
November 30, 2011 1:09 AM

can i believe what you say lol

Comments on this entry are closed.

If you have a question, start by using the search box up at the top of the page - there's a very good chance that your question has already been answered on Ask Leo!.

If you don't find your answer, head out to http://askleo.com/ask to ask your question.