Helping people with computers... one answer at a time.
Scanners are handy ways to get information from paper into your computer. However spreadsheets are highly structured which makes things very difficult.
Can you recommend a good software program for scanning (I have an Epson 1650) and converting documents to Excel 2007? My Epson software will not do this.
No, I can't. And it's not because I don't want to. What you're asking for is very very difficult to do well, if at all. It all has to do with exactly what it means to scan something, and what it means to be an Excel spreadsheet.
The most important thing to realize is that a scan of a document is almost exactly the same as taking a picture of the document. So what you end up with is the equivalent of a ".jpg" picture of the document - even if the scanning software doesn't actually save it before performing other tasks.
A representation of a 'picture' of a light green letter 'A'
A digital picture of a letter is just a collection of individual pixels that are turned on in the appropriate color in the pattern of the original letter.
The second most important thing to realize is that applications such as Word or Excel don't operate on pictures. They operate on documents in specific formats and with data arranged in specific ways. So rather than operating on a picture of the letters ABCD, Word operates on an internal representation of the letter A, the letter B and so on. This way Word, and applications like it, make it easy to edit - say replacing or deleting one of the letters, and reformatting the entire document if needed to reflect the effects of that change.
In Word and Excel and countless other applications, the letter "A" is represented by the number 65.
So the first problem is converting those pictures of letters into the computer's internal representation of the equivalent letter.
Software to solve this problem exists, and is called "optical character recognition" or OCR software. These programs, when given a picture of a page with text, will analyze the image and produce a document with the program's best guess as to what those letters are and how they were organized. Many scanners nowadays actually come with basic OCR software included.
The problem with OCR is that it's never 100% accurate. In fact, it's often far less than that meaning that any OCR'd document will still required a fair amount of cleanup once it's been converted. OCR also has a particularly difficult time with formatting, which can confuse it, or can just be lost.
And, of course, the quality of OCR is also dependant on the quality of the original document scan.
But, after all's said and done, OCR is often a good first step to converting a scanned document back into some kind of editable form.
But what about spreadsheets like Excel?
The problem with spreadsheets is that they contain more than just text. The rows and columns represent structure. OCR software is typically not able to determine the structure of a document from just a scanned image. Some do try, as in the case of trying to determine paragraphs in a more traditional text document.
Unfortunately, scanning and converting the letters and numbers is one thing, but understanding just how that data should be placed into which cells on a spreadsheet is beyond the ability of most OCR software. In fact, I'm not currently aware of any that can do so. (Check the comments to this article, as I'm sure readers will add suggestions.)
Even as OCR technology continues to improve, I'd fully expect there to be spreadsheet based documents that even the best software would never be able to "understand".
My recommendation today is to OCR the document into a the software's best guess at a regular word processing document, and then spend the time to create your new spreadsheet by hand, copy/pasting the data in the ways that you know the spreadsheet should be organized. It is work, but you'll get the spreadsheet you expect.
Comments on this entry are closed.
If you have a question, start by using the search box up at the top of the page - there's a very good chance that your question has already been answered on Ask Leo!.
If you don't find your answer, head out to http://askleo.com/ask to ask your question.