Ask Leo! by Leo A. Notenboom

Why shouldn't I post my email address in a public forum?

Search First! Then browse: Categories | Full Archive | By Date | Newsletter

Home » Internet

Summary: Spammers harvest email via a variety of means. One of the most common is to simply surf the web and look for anything that might be an email address.

So many discussion forums and technical assistance sites, including yours, ask for an email address to post comments, and yet friends tell me never to put my real address in. Sometimes I need to include my email address as part of my comment or question, but I'm told that's even worse! Why is that, and what should I do?

The why is easy.

The what to do? Not so much.

Why is it a bad idea? In a word, spam.

Anything that will put your email address on to a publicly accessible web page will, in all likelihood, cause you to start getting more and more and more and more spam. Why? Because one technique that spammers use is to visit all the web pages that they can, and collect anything that looks like an email address to add to their mailing list.

Here's an example: muchspam@ask-leo.com - now that I've published that email address on the web on this page, even though it's the only place that email address has or will be officially mentioned, it will now start getting spammed. Just because it was published on a web page, and it looks like a valid email address.

So when you include your email address in an on-line posting - say on a discussion board, or even in a comment here on Ask Leo!, you're almost literally asking for spam.

Don't do it.

In my case, you'll notice that in order to post a comment on Ask Leo!, you're required to provide an email address. But notice also, that that email address is not published on the web page (in my case, if you use a valid email address, it's simply a way for me to follow up with you directly should I have a question about your comment). But be careful - not all weblogs and discussion forums hide your email address. Many turn right around and put it on the web page for all to see. Including the spammers.

Before you post anywhere be sure you know what's going to happen to your email address when you do.

Are you a member of a mailing list? Does that mailing list have an on-line archive? Then your email address may be available to the spammers for harvesting. Ever post on Usenet? The email you used is probably already in the spammer's lists. An early Usenet post "before I knew better" is the reason my wife gets hundreds of spam per day.

So use a fake address - or better yet, don't use one at all.

Now, what if you need to post your email address in a publicly accessible place? There are several techniques for obfuscating the address. Here are a couple of my favorites:

askleo at gmail.com
askleo@gmail.seeohem

The first you've probably seen already in other places. It simply requires that you, as a human, realize that the " at " needs to be replaced with "@". My fear is that this technique is also fairly easy to decode by computer, and the spammers will soon catch on.

The second requires some thought. If you sound out "seeohem", you'll realize that it sounds like c, o, m. "com". Hence you realize that the ".seeohem" really means ".com" and can make that translation when you type in the email address.

The biggest drawback to these approaches is that the email links are not clickable. Anything you can click on to get an email address, the spammers can use to harvest it. Even copy-paste doesn't work, for exactly the same reason.

But protecting yourself from spam is important. And not asking for more, is even more important.

Related:

Article C2397 - August 3, 2005

Helpful? Get new articles weekly by email in my FREE newsletter!

Your Name:
Your Email:


Why Subscribe?

Recent Comments
16 Comments

Good point on not using your real email address in your newsgroup posts. This can lead to a lot of spam.

-David
http://www.giganews.com

Posted by: David at November 1, 2006 12:47 PM

recently a couple of people added me on msn. i think because i typed my msn addy on yahooanswer to help a person. i asked one of the person hu added me and he said he typed 'girls msn address' on google. how do i get rid of it from the web?

Posted by: Chani at December 2, 2007 7:57 AM

I've heard about a method, where you can put + sign after @ in gmail.

like shishirmba+this-is-to-prevent-spam@gmail.com

does that really works???

thanks
Shishir
http://www.ausfuhrung.com

Posted by: Shishir at June 17, 2008 3:52 AM

Leo, for Newsgroups, I have had some success with http://www.newsdemon.com when it comes to removing posts I accidentally passed out my real contact info. They can obviously only remove it from their own servers, but at least it is something.

Posted by: John at June 18, 2008 7:20 PM

If you absolutely need to post an address onto a website, or use it for a verification letter, for example...
A good solution I've found is to use a site such as http://spambox.us/ .
This site will give you a temporary email address for as long as you specify. During this time all emails to that address will be forwarded to the address you enter into the site. After the time specified, the address is no longer valid and emails will no longer be forwarded.
You could also block the temp address after you'd received the email you required if you needed to stop the forwarded mails sooner.

Posted by: Stygies at August 12, 2008 12:08 PM

A forum administrator has send a private message to all registered people with all their email addresses listed. Is this an offence to the data protection act of 1988? If so as the forum is hosted in United States, is there such a law in that country? Is there anything that people affected can do?

I'm afraid I'm no legal authority, and that's exactly what it sounds like you need.
- Leo
08-Nov-2008

Posted by: ming at November 7, 2008 9:08 AM

This is nice article. Good point on not using your real email address in your newsgroup posts. This can lead to a lot of spam. And Not that I'm aware of.
---------------
Muthu


[link removed]

Posted by: muthu at November 13, 2008 12:27 PM

Good points. The freedom to post your email address wherever you want is more important though.

[personal email address removed]

Actually the freedom of site owners to protect you from yourself (or from posting someone else's email address so as to get them spam) trumps all. (Read the commenting instructions, and you'll see that it says, clearly, No email addresses.)
- Leo
24-Dec-2008
Posted by: adam at December 23, 2008 3:44 PM

it's true, we get email addresses from lots of sources but blogs and message boards are faves.
[email address removed]

Posted by: acai at January 28, 2009 1:21 PM

Hmm

Posted by: Laura Baugh at April 1, 2009 9:35 PM

Post a comment on "Why shouldn't I post my email address in a public forum?":






(Email Address will not be published.)

Remember Me?

By popular demand...
my tip jar
Cuppa Joe
Buy Leo a Latte!

(you may use HTML tags for style)

RSS feed Subscribe to the RSS Feed specifically for comments on this article.

Before commenting, please...

Please wait. Your comment is being processed ...


Question? Ask Leo!